Litigant environmental organizations may have a harder time getting what they want in court because of a Supreme Court decision related to abortion medication.
According to the Daily Journal, Judge Jennifer Thurston of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California rejected a case in late October from the Sierra Club and Wilderness Society that challenged 25 Bureau of Land Management oil drilling permits by ruling the organizations lacked standing. In other words, she ruled that they failed to meet the legal requirements for bringing a lawsuit.
Her reason for doing so centers on a similar argument in the 2024 Supreme Court case FDA v. Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine. The justices ruled plaintiffs in that case did not prove they received concrete injuries by the Food and Drug Administration actions.
"The advocacy organizations who were plaintiffs in Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine relied on the same types of allegations and the same theory of standing. They contended that the FDA had impaired their 'ability to provide services and achieve their organizational missions,'” wrote Thurston in her decision.
Judge Thurston also cited a 2026 case (Arizona Alliance for Retired Americans v. Mayes) that injury is not established just because a plaintiff objects.
“When an organization’s mission is frustrated just because it has a general objection to the challenged action, the organization has not suffered an injury-in-fact, even when it expends resources to voice that objection,” U.S. Circuit Judge Anthony D. Johnstone wrote, according to Daily Journal.
So, if applying that legal rationale, environmental groups that claim injury because of so-called violations related to wildlife management or forest management may face more of an uphill challenge going forward.
In the California drilling permits case, the judge's dismissal ruling is not set in stone. She gave plaintiffs 30 days to amend and refile their complaint.
About Hunt 2 Conserve
Hunt 2 Conserve is a 501(c)4 nonprofit organization affiliated with the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation. Its mission is to advance a legacy of hunting and conservation by educating, activating and developing stewards and defenders of these fundamentally American ideals. For more information, go to hunt2conserve.org.