Perhaps legendary ESPN sportscaster Chris Berman said it best when he belted out, "Rumblin', stumblin', bumblin!'" But in this case, we are not talking about his description of awkward football highlights like an off-beat fumble or interception. Instead, you can hang his famous tagline on the Colorado Parks and Wildlife Commission for two more days of turbulence, dysfunction and confusion at its latest meetings on Nov. 4-5.
Procedural Inconsistencies
It began with a seemingly routine agenda item of approving minutes from the previous meeting. Commissioner Dallas May made a motion that three of his action items from a September meeting were not addressed at the time in proper order and, therefore, were not but should be placed on the public record. The discussion devolved into 12 minutes of back-and-forth repetition before the commission voted 9-3 to include the action items, with Commissioners Jay Tutchton, Becky Neimec and Jess Beaulieu voting "no."
Tutchton also distributed a one-page guide to try to help commissioners with the procedural process, which has received much negative public attention from past meetings such as the highly confusing gathering in suburban Denver earlier this year.
Citizen Petition Process
Neimec then expressed confusion and a "concern about public trust," asking why her request to consider a wolf petition was not on the November agenda as she wanted. Commissioner Frances Silva Blaney expressed a similar concern asking why a prairie dog petition ended up on the November agenda when others filed earlier were not. Tutchton then stated such decisions are made at his discretion as committee chair, and that he made those decisions after conversations with the Colorado Parks and Wildlife (CPW) director and executive team. Beaulieu then argued the wolf petition should also receive immediate consideration based on when it was originally filed.
Prairie Dog Petition

(Photo credit: Tom Koerner/U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service)
The issue that took the most time, and caused the most contention, was a rushed citizen petition discussion originally introduced in April that calls for banning the shooting of prairie dogs on public land. Six commissioners outvoted five others in September to initiate petition rulemaking and expedite the process for the November meeting instead of waiting for the small game January-March regulatory cycle.
Key to rulemaking for any petition or other issue is a stakeholder procedure that allows CPW to gather information to best educate commissioners about the issue. It is designed to be a thorough, structured process of public engagement with an advisory framework to gather biological science, social data, expert perspectives and other helpful information via public open houses, virtual listening sessions, focus groups and comment from various stakeholders such as agricultural representatives, livestock producers, Tribal nations, hunters, anglers and others that would be impacted or interested.
As a result of the fast-tracked September vote, CPW staff had only eight days to create an informational issue paper for commissioners, a task that takes much longer.
"CPW was not able to engage with stakeholders in time to incorporate their input into the development of this issue paper. A public and stakeholder engagement process to inform the development of regulatory alternatives typically requires 3-4 months to plan, conduct, analyze feedback and report qualitative social data to decision-makers," CPW stated in its issue paper.
Because of the brief window, the only proposals CPW presented were to keep the status quo of allowing the shooting of prairie dogs on public land or ban it altogether. CPW also restated, as in earlier meetings, that peer-reviewed research shows recreational harvest of prairie dogs does not drive population-level declines at a landscape scale.
Commission debate then deteriorated into blatant conduct, confusion and accusations of unfair and unequal treatment. Niemiec showed a random and overly graphic YouTube video of someone shooting prairie dogs while supplying a rambling play-by-play. She referred to the video as "useful" for the discussion. Her tactic was not well received.
“That video is not reflective of who I am as a commissioner, and that is not what we stand for," said Silva Blayney. "That is what the young people today like to call a 'shock video' and is actually the lowest form of debate. We are better than that!"
Two and a half hours of pointed public comment followed that included multiple commissioners from remote Colorado counties pleading for time to communicate with their constituents and allow them to be part of the stakeholder process. Those prolonged comments, along with others from the public, ended day one of the meetings
The following morning, Silva Blayney asked that the commission hold an executive session to discuss legal aspects of the rulemaking. Tutchton, at first, disagreed not seeing a need for it, before complying with fellow commissioners to do so.
Following that session and citing a compilation of 25 studies, which she held in her hand and presented to the commission only moments before the meeting began on day-one, Niemiec cited the information as a basis for her "personal determination that a closure of recreational take on public lands is necessary to maintain the proper ecological balance of the environment."
“I'm listening to the science," agreed Tutchton.
Commissioners May, Tai Jacober and Silva Blayney again questioned the rushed proceedings, urging the need for a thorough stakeholder process with meaningful engagement that would lead to eventually passing a more "robust" rule.
“If we don't trust each other as landowners, as commissioners, as agencies, it's all lost and we will get nowhere. It is ultimately the most important thing we are doing today with the turbulence that's happening with this agency is to continue to form the partnerships we have with landowners," said Jacober.
“It's becoming increasingly popular for a certain segment of our society to self-proclaim themselves 'wildlife advocates' - building themselves up by tearing others down," said May, also a rancher and landowner. "This term has been hijacked and weaponized against people who live on and steward our private lands and the wildlife that depend on it. It also has been misappropriated and used against the great people who are CPW, who devote their lives and careers to protect wildlife and the fragile habitat against extreme threats. Farmers, ranchers and rural communities are being demonized and are being forced to defend themselves against policies that are threatening the work we depend on to sustain our communities...What we're doing right now is not deliberative democracy. We're having a rush to judgement."
Commissioner Peter Maguire expressed his opposition to the shooting prairie dogs on public land but expressed hope that the commission would delay the process to receive adequate stakeholder input. Commissioner Gabriel Otero also admitted "there are gaps in the information we have."
Niemiec, attending just her second commission meeting after being appointed by Gov. Jared Polis, said, "I worry this call for more time is just a tactic to delay decision-making on this until a lot of us are gone. Can we be honest about what's happening here?"
Translation: Niemiec knew any delay in her faction's advancement of the prairie dog petition would mean it would not be addressed until March, which be after a newly-elected governor would take over and possibly remove current members of the commission, including herself. (Important note: the commission usually meets every other month throughout the year or six times total. In this case, the commission planned a new meeting, one in early January, instead of later months so it would take place before the changeover in governor.)
May said the timing of whether members may be removed from the commission by the new governor did not justify skipping the stakeholder process. Jacober then moved that the commission table the decision until a proper stakeholder process be implemented.
"This process has been intellectually dishonest from the beginning," said May.
Silva Blaney then laid out the stakeholder groups that should be part of the process. Arguments continued with May expressing concerns that advancing the issue "puts us in much risk and harm for more litigation," alluding to a July lawsuit filed against the commission claiming it failed to provide sufficient public notice or opportunity to comment before its adoption of a rule that reduced the daily harvest limits of Colorado furbearers.
"I've struggled with this issue for 20 years and never been able to actually get to it, so I'm really upset by this continued delay," said Tutchton.
May, Jacober and Sylva Blaney again brought up the absolute need to have county commissioners and others engaged in a collaborative stakeholder process as they do with other issues.
Beaulieu called for an immediate vote on Jacober's motion. Commissioners voted it down.
Niemiec then proposed a basic motion for formal rulemaking to take place in January.
"No solution is perfect. I'm really tired of doing nothing," said Tutchton, who sought to clarify Niemiec's motion with legal counsel sitting next to him and then made one of his own.
"It's clearly apparent we're rushing and there's confusion," Jacober said about the multiple motions. "What does public lands mean? How are we supposed to make a rulemaking when we don’t even know? As commissioners, how are we supposed to vote on it? We’re rushing this because we haven’t given staff the opportunity to work through the legal parts of it, let alone the stakeholder engagement part of it. Really?"
Jacober also told Niemiec and Beaulieu that their smiles during the confusion were not appropriate. His comment came as "multiple commissioners appeared to be actively sending and receiving text messages," as reported by the Fence Post, which also reported Gov. Polis called at least one commissioner urging a vote in favor of the petition.
"We're rushing this...I'm done!" concluded Jacober.
“That does not bother me at this juncture because when we finally vote on this in January, we’ll know exactly what the definition of public lands that we end up voting on in January will be,” said Tutchton.
“So, what you’re saying is that we should vote on something and we don’t have the definition for this very important language that’s in the motion, and that we don’t need to worry about it because we’ll be doing a final vote in January,” said Silva Blaney.
Her comments triggered applause and voiced snickers from the public in attendance.
"You may be entitled to laugh at us but please do so silently," Tutchton chided, who then moved the process forward with the commission approving the petition's shooting ban on a 6-5 vote.
CPW staff now must assemble a rulemaking framework for the January commission meeting but because of the compacted demand and holiday season, it will have an extremely truncated timeframe to do so.
Would a final "yes" ruling affect federal land?
Yes, as it is currently written.
The draft defines “public land” as federal lands plus land owned or administered by CPW. That would cover lands managed by the Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Forest Service including national grasslands and national wildlife refuges, CPW properties and some State Land Board lands where CPW manages hunting access. But since the term "public land" remains undefined, it is unclear.
"Leased land" is especially murky. Under CO Revised Statute Title 33, landowners and lessees can take prairie dogs causing damage on land they own or lease, but much of that State Land Board ground and federal grazing land is leased to ranchers. Until revised language comes out, it is not clear which parcels are in or out, or how much CPW could actually control on leased ground.
What would approving the petition actually do?
It would close the prairie dog season on public land entirely, with no season and a zero-bag limit. It is also broader than a shooting ban since it covers all recreational take, which is what petitioners confirmed they want. It is stated that private land would not change at all, and landowners and lessees could still take prairie dogs that are damaging crops, property or livestock. County rodent control authority also stays in place, although CPW's issue paper admits it is "unclear" about how far county authority reaches when conflicting with wildlife statutes.
The final vote is scheduled January 6-7, 2027, in Westminster. There will be another opportunity for public comment at that time, although it is more of a formality as commissioners seem hellbent to go forward with their desires. However, for the rule to pass, the commission must make a formal finding that closing the season is necessary to maintain prairie dog populations or the ecological balance. This is also somewhat convoluted given that CPW's paper says populations are healthy and that recreational shooting is not what drives declines.
When would it take effect?
If formal rulemaking is adopted in January, the ban would not take effect until the next season opens on June 15, 2027. The current season runs through the end of February.
About Hunt 2 Conserve
Hunt 2 Conserve is a 501(c)4 nonprofit organization affiliated with the Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation. Its mission is to advance a legacy of hunting and conservation by educating, activating and developing stewards and defenders of these fundamentally American ideals. For more information, go to hunt2conserve.org.